Blog

My response to Kai Stinchcombe

12/25/2017

The anniversary article reflecting on Ten Years of Bitcoin triggered a storm of heated debates. And no wonder–it was a great write-up launched at the best possible time—the calm silence before Christmas, when no one is working and everyone has plenty of time to lazily wander around the house and wonder, with a craving for juicy news.

Kai makes a number of excellent arguments, but he seems to be knocking at the window while missing the wide open door.

 

Let’s start with the basics...The “Ten Years” Argument

It’s common knowledge that Bitcoin was first released at the end of 2009 (version 0.1). A number of bugs were discovered and resolved between 2009 and 2013. Looking at the issues that were addressed back then (transaction malleability, unexpected network fork, etc.), it is hard to associate the word “stable” with it at any time before early to mid 2014, even with the caveats and disclaimers one often uses to handwave road bumps with any new technology. For all practical purposes, the age of Bitcoin as an applicable, functional technology rather than an abstract concept is less than three to four years old.

By all practical measures, three to four years means a technology is still in its infancy. ARPANET, the precursor to the Internet, was established as early as in 1983, but it took seven to ten years before we saw the explosive growth of the 90s. That being said, someone in 1994 could have written a perfectly logical article titled “Ten years later, no one’s come up with a use for the Internet,” for example.

It took another ten years for fundamental changes in travel, stock trading and a number of other industries to take place. In fact, the overwhelming shift to online shopping over brick and mortar didn’t happen until 2010 or later.

Social media and the online advertising industry that it facilitated didn’t hit their stride until the mid-2000s. After that it took another 10 years for online advertisement to finally wrest control from TV and print, only really occurring in the last year or two. All in all, it took 20 years or so for Internet to deliver on its promises. Why would be Bitcoin or any other manifestation of blockchain be any different?

 

Disruption of existing industries: payments, stocks, banking, distributed storage…

If history offers any lessons, the disruption of an existing industry does not happen simply as a result of the invention of new technology. New business models, fueled by the technology or creative applications in the context of existing models, are instead often the cause of a disruption to the paradigm. It’s not that unusual for existing players to embrace and prosper with new inventions rather than allowing themselves to become obsolete.

We still buy cars from dealers—but the majority of car shopping happens online. Did dealers go out of business? Not quite. The smarter ones embraced “the online” to drive even more sales than before.

Stock trading — today many investors trade using online brokerage accounts. Charles Schwab saw lots of early success as a pioneer in online trading. Did any broker go out of business as stock trading shifted to the internet? I’m sure some did. Did others survive and become even stronger—that’s not even a question.

Bitcoin and blockchain are no different than other technology innovations we’ve seen before. In fact, history is repeating itself right in front of our eyes.

Nasdaq and a few others united behind R3—the consortium looking to enable trading on the blockchain. The hope is to simplify the stock settlement across market participants—a manual, involved process that takes up to three days to complete after the purchase. Yes, you read that right—it takes around three days for your one-click purchase to finally settle and register in all affected books. Could the blockchain provide a superior alternative? It’s easy to see that it should be explored, at least.

Visa and MasterCard operate a global network of connected and mutually trusted nodes. Lots of work goes into certification, audit, and secure operation of individual nodes. Could blockchain ease some of the requirements as a result of its trustless model? Absolutely! Is it possible that payment costs will be lower as a result? No doubt. Does it mean the world of plastic cards must switch to the blockchain for each and every payment? Absolutely not!

There is no need to consider extremes—no need to aim for the extinction of a business or a vertical for blockchain to succeed. There are plenty of opportunities to compliment, enhance, and extend.

 

Where are the opportunities?

Joe—the cool guy—launched a file storage service and offers it cheaper than S3. Would you trust him with your sensitive files? Not likely. What if the payment for Joe’s service was cryptographically contingent on your retrieval of files and matching of hash codes? We just replaced the trust to the unknown party Joe with trust in the integrity of a decentralized network, supported by hundreds of billions in individual investments that is unlikely to go away anytime soon. Clearly, there is an opportunity for Joe and his customers.

Joe launches a Kickstarter campaign on a new, cool IOT device. The campaign goes well, devices are shipped, Joe maintains a server with device registration. Suddenly Joe goes out of business, taking the servers with him and rendering the devices useless. Would it be better if the registration data was stored in a blockchain, eliminating the risk of owning a device that outlived the manufacturer?

More on this point—the number of accounts and registration records is exploding with the growth of the consumer and industrial IOT. Account maintenance is becoming a serious expenditure, affecting margins and profitability. At the same time, it is almost never a core business function for an IOT maker, who would happily hand it over elsewhere. Clever developers at Xage (https://xage.com/) have already deployed an account management solution for industrial IOT (Disclaimer: I am not involved with Xage in any form or fashion).

Despite the hysteria surrounding the Experian story, anyone with meaningful experience in corporate IT would say that Experian is not any worse than the average. In fact, not better or worse, just average. The issue is not that they should have been better. It is rather the enormous concentration of data creating unbearable risks.

In absence of better alternatives, Experian must be the collector of records and the custodian, compute FICO and perform a number of other functions that leads to enormous risk concentration. An alternative that stores records on the chain and only infrequently opens access to Experian and other parties based on explicit customer authorization could be much more secure and reliable, leading to a clear win-win. Notice that credit ratings did not go away, credit agencies did not get replaced with the blockchain, but rather agencies became a participant in a new engagement model.

I could go on for hours, but hopefully the overall premise is clear by now:

  • Bitcoin and blockchain should not be evaluated in the context of head-to-head competition looking to drive incumbents into obsolescence.
  • Similar to the Internet and other innovations, Bitcoin and blockchain will take time to mature.

 

Technologies do not change the world, business models do.

Comments

Submitted by aureliacq18 on Sat, 06/11/2022 - 14:05

Big Ass Photos - Free Huge Butt Porn, Big Booty Pics
http://desert.airepornfor1dollar.danexxx.com/?ainsley
wife fucking big cock porn porn stars wax or shave japan public molest video porn sex free porn solo vids andjob porn vidios

Submitted by aureliacq18 on Sat, 06/11/2022 - 14:08

College Girls Porn Pics
http://watchpornmobilekwigillingok.danexxx.com/?yadira
60 pluse mlif porn lovethe free porn videos free marure women porn limewires top porn downloads bizaare porn video

Submitted by aureliacq18 on Sat, 06/11/2022 - 14:39

Sexy teen photo galleries
http://gfpornitouch.cascadia.alypics.com/?katrina
free videos for porn best rated dvd porn 2008 porn vixens share adult porn schoolgirls free porn photos

Submitted by aureliacq18 on Sat, 06/11/2022 - 15:03

Hot photo galleries blogs and pictures
http://hardcrushporn.novelty.energysexy.com/?kaiya
tsn porn porn doctor hits on patient ipod porn streaming new releases on dvd porn fucked up and nasty porn videos

Submitted by aureliacq18 on Sat, 06/11/2022 - 15:06

Free Porn Galleries - Hot Sex Pictures
http://kanakox.com/?piper
peru video porn new retro porn movie heatwave porn dvd free short porn movies online bamboo porn dtar free streaming videos

Submitted by aureliacq18 on Sat, 06/11/2022 - 16:33

Girls of Desire: All babes in one place, crazy, art
http://mount.carrollsuicidegirlporn.hotnatalia.com/?olivia
porn star capri annette wong porn amatuer porn mother son lrsbian gay porn virtual porn to look yunger

Submitted by aureliacq18 on Sat, 06/11/2022 - 16:56

Dirty Porn Photos, daily updated galleries
http://swingers.porn.hotnatalia.com/?angelina
preston janet porn collection of free porn movies simpsons porn buffers clarence thomas porn film 191 wow gnome porn puddin

Submitted by aureliacq18 on Sat, 06/11/2022 - 17:47

New project started to be available today, check it out
http://miyuhot.com/?theresa
danelle rogers porn tube rabbit porn videos vintage 60s porn uma thurman porn videos twink porn hub

Submitted by aureliacq18 on Sat, 06/11/2022 - 19:43

Sexy pictures each day
http://gasquetdisneypornclis.energysexy.com/?kaley
70s dutch porn classic porn star sex milf facial porn little girl nude porn play videos free porn swinger parties

Submitted by aureliacq18 on Sat, 06/11/2022 - 19:58

Sexy pictures each day
http://hentais.porngann.adablog69.com/?yasmin
mature momfree porn movies anime with porn in porn porn star gets pissed mp3 porn teen itouch porn site xtreme

Submitted by aureliacq18 on Sat, 06/11/2022 - 20:31

Big Ass Photos - Free Huge Butt Porn, Big Booty Pics
http://sexjanet.com/?alia
softcore porn movies free porn databse free porn thumbsup wallpapers of porn columbus porn

Submitted by aureliacq18 on Sat, 06/11/2022 - 22:30

Hot galleries, thousands new daily.
http://massage.porn.higden.alexysexy.com/?malia
porn trailer please band my wife great women in porn porn under 17 top ten free stream porn thai boys oldmen porn

Submitted by aureliacq18 on Sat, 06/11/2022 - 22:34

Hardcore Galleries with hot Hardcore photos
http://canton.porn.topanasex.com/?alia
free brazzar office porn animal porn to watch online free teen cartoon porn free ametuer gay porn videos gonzo anal porn

Submitted by aureliacq18 on Sat, 06/11/2022 - 23:13

Sexy teen photo galleries
http://miyuhot.com/?marisol
gay porn magazines in usa fit girl porn japanies woman porn hollys porn pic from playboy emo porn galleries

Submitted by aureliacq18 on Sun, 06/12/2022 - 01:43

Scandal porn galleries, daily updated lists
http://penuelas.sockjobporn.adablog69.com/?emerson
brandy taylor porn movies palin porn game how big is internet porn addiction porn mother daughter first time nwo porn music

Submitted by aureliacq18 on Sun, 06/12/2022 - 01:55

Free Porn Pictures and Best HD Sex Photos
http://moesexy.com/?aliya
free porn for paid sites porn tube green sweater office desk high resolution scans porn cougar and kitten free porn videos samsung instinct shemale porn

Submitted by aureliacq18 on Sun, 06/12/2022 - 03:16

Free Porn Galleries - Hot Sex Pictures
http://sex.moesexy.com/?yessenia
biggest clitoris in porn nadia nitro porn clips porn wifes making men suck perfect porn stars size matters 3 porn

Submitted by aureliacq18 on Sun, 06/12/2022 - 04:34

Hot teen pics
http://adultpornforums.kendallville.alypics.com/?evelyn
join gay porn free ameature porn pics cartoon free porn pictures cinderella porn movie teen girl porn picture galleries

Submitted by aureliacq18 on Sun, 06/12/2022 - 04:38

New hot project galleries, daily updates
http://boardman.jsutandy.com/?mireya
porn removal shareware miniature women in porn xxx porn nakita denise double d housewives 3 porn free forced rough attack porn

Submitted by aureliacq18 on Sun, 06/12/2022 - 04:39

Scandal porn galleries, daily updated lists
http://gigixo.com/?jordyn
porn industry destroys women cartoon 10 porn old man office porn free teen lingerie porn galleries free gay medical porn

Submitted by aureliacq18 on Sun, 06/12/2022 - 07:04

Hardcoee Galleries with hot Hardcore photos
http://animayporngamesvenedy.topanasex.com/?felicia
squirting porn samples free no down lowed lesbien porn real porn hub celeb porn torcher female warriors fantasy porn

Submitted by aureliacq18 on Sun, 06/12/2022 - 07:26

New super hot photo galleries, daily updated collections
http://miaxxx.com/?ashleigh
striptease free porn videos watertorture porn websites free gay college guy porn free porn debby does dalles watch mature women porn photo

Submitted by aureliacq18 on Sun, 06/12/2022 - 07:33

Dirty Porn Photos, daily updated galleries
http://fitchburg.gaymexicanporn.hotnatalia.com/?arely
sandra bullock anal sex porn hinti porn porn in parchis clara morgane in porn free girl on porn

Submitted by aureliacq18 on Sun, 06/12/2022 - 10:15

My new hot project|enjoy new website
http://jsutandy.com/?faith
venezuelan women porn meghan girlfriend porn drunk mom son sex porn top free indian porn sites the incredibles porn picture galleries

Submitted by aureliacq18 on Sun, 06/12/2022 - 10:18

Hot galleries, thousands new daily.
http://avillavingeporn.reinerton.adablog69.com/?yvette
hip hop video vixen porn soft core porn free streaming dee baker porn zoe dorman raven porn porn industry jobs minneapolis

Submitted by aureliacq18 on Sun, 06/12/2022 - 10:25

New project started to be available today, check it out
http://barkerpornstarlovette.hotnatalia.com/?raina
free mobil phone porn no viruses horse cum porn chubby vivian alesi porn nude blond women interracial porn san fransisco ameture porn

Submitted by aureliacq18 on Sun, 06/12/2022 - 13:08

Free Porn Galleries - Hot Sex Pictures
http://kanakox.com/?briana
utube porn strip tease washington state porn warcaft porn hot white girl porn 70 s porn tubes

Submitted by aureliacq18 on Sun, 06/12/2022 - 13:17

Sexy photo galleries, daily updated collections
http://northcorbin.animalspermporn.lexixxx.com/?marina
dread porn movie euro porn tube videos first time hardcore porn porn hub fat woman latina porn ice la fox

Submitted by aureliacq18 on Sun, 06/12/2022 - 13:19

Hot new pictures each day
http://nahunta.miaxxx.com/?anjali
porn of disny chanal peple lesbian animae porn couples first porn anime fairytale porn free 90 s teen porn video

Submitted by aureliacq18 on Sun, 06/12/2022 - 14:36

Hot galleries, thousands new daily.
http://lulashoupornvideo.alexysexy.com/?delilah
xxx porn fuck movies free soft porn photography milked porn youngt teen porn justin tmie porn star

Submitted by aureliacq18 on Sun, 06/12/2022 - 15:28

Sexy photo galleries, daily updated collections
http://deming.porn.amandahot.com/?jaliyah
trailers porn free porn week iniform porn softcore porn on netflix steven st croix online porn videos

Submitted by aureliacq18 on Sun, 06/12/2022 - 16:12

Hot new pictures each day
http://divideromanricporn.alexysexy.com/?alanna
daddy spanks porn porn twins male free femail body buider porn free crotch prn videos porn free video galleries

Submitted by aureliacq18 on Sun, 06/12/2022 - 16:14

Scandal porn galleries, daily updated lists
http://bigwellspeachpornlabel.energysexy.com/?kali
strightjacket porn best classic 70 s porn movie mobile teen porn sex free mobil porn blackberry ventage english porn

Submitted by aureliacq18 on Sun, 06/12/2022 - 19:27

Girls of Desire: All babes in one place, crazy, art
http://porntvshowp2pclarcona.topanasex.com/?dania
reality outdoor porn movies buenos aeres gay porn katie james hard core porn tube negima porn quiz teen porn babe videos lesbian

Submitted by aureliacq18 on Sun, 06/12/2022 - 20:12

Enjoy daily galleries
http://buncetonpornpayable.hoterika.com/?susana
world of warcraft porn edition best porn catergories wendy kennedy porn gay teen hommade porn videos danica blue eskimoporn

Submitted by aureliacq18 on Sun, 06/12/2022 - 22:25

Sexy pictures each day
http://divideromanricporn.alexysexy.com/?alice
porn youtube homade hookers tranny porn staes free video fresh petals porn animal porn men fucking goats andie porn vidoes

Submitted by aureliacq18 on Sun, 06/12/2022 - 23:09

Sexy teen photo galleries
http://celebrity.porn.kanakox.com/?tamia
gay porn brian carlin galleries porn videos brazzers free mobile porn app for blackberry cartoon of mliy cyris porn video free uk teen porn video

Submitted by aureliacq18 on Mon, 06/13/2022 - 01:28

Sexy photo galleries, daily updated collections
http://stratton.alypics.com/?kellie
bllack porn eypt porn you porn nude not 18 porn infantalism free porn

Submitted by aureliacq18 on Mon, 06/13/2022 - 02:23

Big Ass Photos - Free Huge Butt Porn, Big Booty Pics
http://tehuacanatennpornvideos.hotnatalia.com/?kiana
3gp phone porn downloads masked fantasy porn round tits you poen blond blowjob porn pic galleries daughter and father free porn videos

Submitted by aureliacq18 on Mon, 06/13/2022 - 03:04

Daily updated super sexy photo galleries
http://german.porn.alexysexy.com/?amira
porn xxx tube hidden camera actress to porn star arid porn video shelley porn ftv porn of the dead mp4 torrent

Submitted by aureliacq18 on Mon, 06/13/2022 - 03:52

Scandal porn galleries, daily updated lists
http://pornshylastylezravine.hoterika.com/?jordyn
viewer sub porn porn vinage british porn star georgina smith rihanna look a like porn free porn nappies

Submitted by aureliacq18 on Mon, 06/13/2022 - 05:13

Free Porn Pictures and Best HD Sex Photos
http://stemnudistspornsexy.danexxx.com/?macie
ballbusting porn videos male black porn star remy porn mustashe picture young teen porn passwords bbw fuck porn

Submitted by aureliacq18 on Mon, 06/13/2022 - 06:26

Sexy pictures each day
http://boothwyn.porn90sstars.energysexy.com/?robyn
palin porn tube hot anthro porn young bbw girls porn xxx mother son porn sex hakan serben porn

Submitted by aureliacq18 on Mon, 06/13/2022 - 07:40

Nude Sex Pics, Sexy Naked Women, Hot Girls Porn
http://oak.shoresgridleporn.miyuhot.com/?elaina
young boy porn site defecates porn watch free pov porn kelly blue porn stsr risa murakami porn

Submitted by aureliacq18 on Mon, 06/13/2022 - 10:29

Browse over 500 000 of the best porn galleries, daily updated collections
http://pornandboobs.parkercity.miaxxx.com/?ximena
porn parody streaming free hetia porn movies free aurora snow porn young girls boys porn picture galleries how to draw furry porn

Submitted by aureliacq18 on Mon, 06/13/2022 - 10:58

Sexy teen photo galleries
http://lovettsville.youngtubeporn.danexxx.com/?yadira
only sex porn videos backdoor boys 2 gay porn dvd amatuer porn podcast inappropriate teen porn long femdom porn tubes

Submitted by aureliacq18 on Mon, 06/13/2022 - 14:06

Girls of Desire: All babes in one place, crazy, art
http://lakeland.pornstarshairy.adablog69.com/?felicity
unscensored porn free hardcore gay twink porn dana smith cherub porn real street whores porn anna addison porn

Submitted by aureliacq18 on Mon, 06/13/2022 - 14:15

College Girls Porn Pics
http://bremond.voyeur.porn.moesexy.com/?josie
free gay porn website amature porn cum shots free brazian porn pictures free facial porn galleries katie cummings porn video

Submitted by aureliacq18 on Mon, 06/13/2022 - 15:45

Sexy photo galleries, daily updated pics
http://avergeblackporn.tannersville.amandahot.com/?cynthia
mom and daughter toon porn roast beef pussy porn gay porn free traileres fre black porn videos phat azz porn video

Submitted by aureliacq18 on Mon, 06/13/2022 - 16:31

Hot galleries, daily updated collections
http://durandfatgirlsoloporn.jsutandy.com/?johana
top heavy asian granny porn forced family porn free porn previews anna nicole smith country girl porn amatuar porn trailer

Pages